@react-types/menu
Spectrum UI components in React
This package has a good security score with no known vulnerabilities.
Community Reviews
Solid TypeScript definitions for React Spectrum menus, minimal learning curve
The learning curve is gentle if you're already familiar with TypeScript and React. The type definitions are self-documenting with clear property names and sensible defaults. Error messages are typical TypeScript fare—helpful when you pass wrong prop types, though not particularly enlightened about menu-specific patterns. One minor frustration: the relationship between @react-types, @react-aria, and @react-spectrum packages isn't immediately obvious from documentation, so expect some initial confusion about which package does what.
Day-to-day usage is smooth once you understand the Adobe React Spectrum ecosystem. The types catch most mistakes at compile time, and IntelliSense works excellently. GitHub issues get responses, though the modular package structure means you sometimes need to hunt for the right repo to file issues against.
Best for: Teams building accessible menu systems with TypeScript who want strong type safety and are using React Aria or React Spectrum.
Avoid if: You need standalone menu components without adopting the React Spectrum ecosystem or prefer simpler, all-in-one component libraries.
Solid TypeScript definitions for React Spectrum menus, minimal runtime overhead
The types align cleanly with @react-aria and @react-stately, making it straightforward to build custom menu implementations while maintaining type safety. Breaking changes between versions are rare and well-documented in changelogs. The separation of types into their own package is actually beneficial for dependency management - you can reference these types without pulling in implementation code.
From an operations perspective, there's literally nothing to worry about - no connection pooling, no retries, no logging hooks needed. It's just type definitions. The only gotcha is ensuring version alignment with your actual React Spectrum components to avoid type mismatches, but semantic versioning handles this reasonably well.
Best for: Projects using React Spectrum or building custom accessible menu components with strong TypeScript requirements.
Avoid if: You're not using TypeScript or building menus outside the React Spectrum/Aria ecosystem.
Well-typed type definitions for React Aria menus with excellent IDE support
The type definitions integrate seamlessly with React Aria's composable architecture. You get proper inference for generics when working with collections, and discriminated unions help catch errors at compile time rather than runtime. Error messages are generally clear when you misuse props, though occasionally the generic constraints can produce verbose error output.
One minor annoyance is that this is a separate package from the actual component implementation, so you need to ensure version alignment between @react-types/menu and @react-aria/menu or @react-spectrum/menu. The types are also quite strict, which is mostly good but can require type assertions in edge cases where you're doing something unusual with menu composition.
Best for: TypeScript projects using React Aria or React Spectrum that need robust type safety for menu components.
Avoid if: You're using plain JavaScript or need a batteries-included menu component without the compositional approach.
Sign in to write a review
Sign In